Defining Boundaries: Towards an Identity of The Malaysian Third Sector
Reviews of the literature suggest the Malaysian third sector lacks basic descriptive information. Research on what makes up the sector is scarce, indicating little effort was undertaken to define and identify its components from the Malaysian perspective. This paper proposes the scope of the Malaysian third sector by suggesting its boundaries and identifying the constituents. Inclusion was based on the structural-operational definition of third sector organisations developed by Salamon and Anheier (1992, 1996) and the primary basis for exclusion is distribution of profits to shareholders and promoters. It is proposed that social, voluntary, non-governmental and nonprofit organisations make up the Malaysian third sector, while state linked organisations and profit-distributing organisations such as cooperatives and social enterprises are excluded. Knowing the third sector’s boundaries and constituents would allow more focussed research to be undertaken; enabling actors, researchers, and policymakers to identify issues and develop policies and strategies to address them.
Arshad, M. N. M., & Haneef, M. A. M. (2016). Third Sector Socio-Economic Models: How Waqf Fits In? Institutions and Economies, 8(2), 72-90.
Banks, N. & Brockington, D. (2019). Mapping the UK’s development NGOs: income, geography and contributions to international development. GDI Working Paper 2019-035. University of Manchester.
Barman, E. (2013). Classificatory struggles in the nonprofit sector: The formation of the National Taxonomy of Exempt Entities, 1969–1987. Social Science History, 37(1), 103-141.
Billis, D. (2010). Towards a theory of hybrid organizations. In Hybrid organizations and the third sector: challenges for practice, theory and policy, 46-69. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.
Birchall, J. & Ketilson, L. H. (2009). Resilience of the cooperative business model in times of crisis. International Labour Organisation.
Brandsen, T., Van de Donk, W., & Putters, K. (2005). Griffins or chameleons? Hybridity as a permanent and inevitable characteristic of the third sector. International Journal of Public Administration, 28(9-10), 749-765.
Brenton, M. (1985). The voluntary sector in British social services. London, Longman.
Brown, L. D., and Korten, D. C. (1989). Understanding Voluntary Organizations: Guidelines for Donors. No. WPS 258, The World Bank.
Bunyan, P. (2014). Re-conceptualizing Civil Society: Towards a Radical Understanding, Voluntas, 25(2), 538-552
Casey, J. (2016). Comparing nonprofit sectors around the world: What do we know and how do we know it? The Journal of Nonprofit Education and Leadership, 6(3):187-223.
Casey, J. (2020). Comparing Third Sector Expansions. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice. 22(1), 1-5
Che Soh, M., Tumin, M. (2017). Sejarah dan perkembagan badan bukan kerajaan (NGO) kesihatan di Malaysia sehingga tahun 2015. SEJARAH: Journal of the Department of History, 26(2), 49-70.
Corry, O. (2010). Defining and theorizing the third sector. In Third sector research, 11-20. Springer.
Defourny, J. & Develtere, P. (2009). The social economy: the worldwide making of a third sector. In The Worldwide Making of the Social Economy. Innovations and Changes, 15-40). Acco.
Defourny, J. & Pestoff, V. (2014). Towards a European conceptualization of the Third sector. In Accountability and Social Accounting for Social and Nonprofit Organizations, 25-87. Emerald.
DiMaggio, P. J. & Anheier, H. K. (1990). The sociology of nonprofit organizations and sectors. Annual Review of Sociology, 16(1), 137-159.
Douglas, S. A., & Pedersen, P. (1973). Blood, believer, and brother: The development of voluntary associations in Malaysia. Center for International Studies, Ohio University.
Enache, C. (2020). Sources of government revenue in the OECD. Washington DC. Tax Foundation
Etzioni, A. 1973. The third sector and domestic missions. Public Administration Review, 33(4), 314-323.
Evers, A., & Laville, J. (2004). Defining the Third Sector in Europe. In The Third Sector in Europe, 11-42. Edward Elgar.
Fajardo Garcia, G. (2012). Cooperative finance and cooperative identity. Paper presented at the Cooperative Law in Europe: New Challenges and Perspectives, Manchester.
Farouk, A. 2011 The limits of civil society in democratising the state: the Malaysian case. Kajian Malaysia, 29(1), 91-109.
Fiss, P. C. (2011). Building better causal theories: A fuzzy set approach to typologies in organization research. Academy of Management Journal, 54, 393-420.
Goodin, R. E. (2003). Democratic accountability: The distinctiveness of the third sector. European Journal of Sociology/Archives Européennes De Sociologie, 44(3), 359-396.
Greve, C., Flinders, M., & Van Thiel, S. 1999. Quangos—what's in a name? Defining quangos from a comparative perspective. Governance, 12(2), 129-146.
Hall, P. D. (1987). A historical overview of the private nonprofit sector. In The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, 3-26. Yale University Press.
Hansmann, H. (2013). All Firms are Cooperatives–and so are Governments. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity, 2(2), 1-10.
Hansmann, H. (1980). The Role of Nonprofit Enterprise. The Yale Law Journal, 89(5), 835-901.
Hansmann, H. (1987). Economic theories of nonprofit organizations. In The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, 27-42. Yale University Press.
Hasan, S. (2015). Disseminating Asia’s third sector research. Voluntas, 26(4), 1007-1015.
Hasnan, S., Abidin, Z. Z., Mohamad, M., & Kamarudin, N. (2012). Issues, challenges and the way forward for charitable organizations in Malaysia. Paper presented at the IEEE Symposium on Business, Engineering and Industrial Applications.
Heng, P. K. (1996). Chinese Responses to Malay Hegemony in Peninsular Malaysia 1957-96. Japanese Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 34(3), 500-523.
Kalmi, P. (2007). The disappearance of cooperatives from economics textbooks. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 31(4), 625-647.
Kasim, M. Y., Berma, M., Nga, J., and Hasan, S. (2006). Philanthropy and the Third Sector in Malaysia: Overview, Extent, Activities, and Impacts. Asia Pacific Philanthropy Information Network https://ssrn.com/abstract=3010039
Kendall, J., & Knapp, M. (1995). A Loose and Baggy Monster: Boundaries, Definitions and Typologies. In An Introduction to the Voluntary Sector, 65-94. Routledge.
Khoo, K. K. (1992). The "Indian association movement" in Peninsular Malaysia: The early years. Journal of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, 65(2(263)), 3-24.
Knutsen, W. (2016). The nonprofit sector is dead, long live the nonprofit sector! Voluntas, 27(4), 1562-1584.
Lewis, D. (2010). Nongovernmental organizations, definition and history. International Encyclopedia of Civil Society, 1056-1062.
Lorentzen, H. (2010). Sector labels. In Third sector research, 21-35. Springer.
Lyons, M. (2001). Third Sector: The contribution of non-profit and cooperative enterprise in Australia. Allen & Unwin
Malaysian Global Innovation and Creativity Centre (MaGIC). (2015). Malaysian Social Enterprise Blueprint 2015-2018: Unleashing the power of social entrepreneurship. Cyberjaya: Social Entrepreneurship Unit
Martens, K. (2002). Mission impossible? Defining nongovernmental organizations. Voluntas, 13(3), 271-285.
McKinney, J. C. (1969). Typification, Typologies, and Sociological Theory. Social Forces, 48(1), 1–12.
Mohan, J. (2011). Mapping the big society: perspectives from the Third Sector Research Centre. No. 62, Third Sector Research Centre.
Morris, S. (2000). Defining the nonprofit sector: Some lessons from history. Voluntas, 11(1), 25-43.
Moulaert, F., & Ailenei, O. (2005). Social economy, third sector and solidarity relations: A conceptual synthesis from history to present. Urban Studies, 42(11), 2037-2053.
Musa, M. (2006). Malay secret societies in the northern Malay states, 1821-1940s. Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society.
Najam, A. (2000) The Four-C’s of Third Sector– Government Relations: Cooperation, Confrontation, Complementarity, and Co-optation. Nonprofit Management & Leadership, 10(4), 375-396.
Nilsson, L. (2010). Cooperatives in transition: Studies of Ownership during a Merger. Licentiate thesis, Department of Economics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences.
Ott, J. S., & Dicke, L. A. (2012). The Nature of the Nonprofit Sector. Westview Press.
Princen, T., Finger, M., and Manno, J. (1995). Nongovernmental organizations in world environmental politics. International Environmental Affairs, 7(1), 42-58.
Reed, P. B., & Howe, V. J. (1999). Defining and classifying the nonprofit sector. Statistics Canada. http://www3.carleton.ca/casr/Defining.pdf
Rich, P. (1992). The Organizational Taxonomy: Definition and Design. Academy of Management Review, 17(4), 758–781.
Salamon, L. (2010). Putting the Civil Society Sector on the Economic Map of the World. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 81(2), 167-210
Salamon, L. M., & Anheier, H. K. (1992). In Search of the Non-profit Sector II: The Problem of Classification. Voluntas, 3(3), 267–309.
Salamon, L. M., and Anheier, H. K. (1996). The International Classification of Nonprofit Organizations: ICNPO-Revision 1, 1996. No. 19, Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies.
Salamon, L. M., Hems, L. C., & Chinnock, K. (2000). The nonprofit sector: for what and for whom? No. 37, Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies.
Salamon, L. M., & Sokolowski, S. W. (2016). Beyond nonprofits: Re-conceptualizing the third sector. Voluntas, 27(4), 1515-1545.
Salamon, L.M., Sokolowski, S.W., & Haddock, M.A. (2017). Explaining Civil Society Development: A Social Origins Approach. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Sidel, M. (2003). Trends in nonprofit self-regulation in the Asia Pacific region: Initial data on initiatives, experiments and models in seventeen countries. Paper presented at the Asia Pacific Philanthropy Consortium Conference on Governance, Organizational Effectiveness and the Nonprofit Sector, Manila.
System of National Accounts (2008). https://unstats.un.org/unsd/nationalaccount/sna2008.asp (accessed January 2021)
Thompson, E. C. (2004). Rural villages as socially urban spaces in Malaysia. Urban Studies, 41(12), 2357-2376.
Toepler, S. (2003). Grassroots associations versus larger nonprofits: New evidence from a community case study in arts and culture. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 32(2), 236-251.
Tumin, M., & Nurhadi, R. (2007). Sejarah dan perkembangan badan bukan kerajaan (NGO) di Malaysia. Jurnal Sejarah, 15(15), 161-176.
Vakil, A. C. (1997). Confronting the classification problem: Toward a taxonomy of NGOs. World Development, 25(12), 2057-2070.
Wagner, A. (2012). ‘Third sector’ and/or ‘civil society’: a critical discourse about scholarship relating to intermediate organisations. Voluntary Sector Review, 3(3), 299-328
Weisbrod, B. A. (1972). Toward a theory of the voluntary nonprofit sector in a three-sector economy. Paper presented at the Conference on Altruism and Economic Theory, New York
Weiss, M. (2005). Prickly ambivalence: State, society and semidemocracy in Malaysia Commonwealth & Comparative Politics, 43(1), 61-81.
Weiss, M. L., & Hassan, S. (2003). Social Movement Malaysia: From moral communities to NGOs. RoutledgeCurzon.
Werker, E., & Ahmed, F. Z. (2008). What do nongovernmental organizations do? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 22(2), 73-92.
Wu, F. (2003). Environmental GONGO autonomy: Unintended consequences of state strategies in China. The Good Society, 12(1), 35-45.
Yusof, Z. A., & Bhattasali, D. (2008). Economic growth and development in Malaysia: policy making and leadership. No. 27, International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank.