Navigating Party Loyalty and Party Hopping in Malaysia Through Nordin Salleh and Khaliq Mehtab’s Cases

Hershan @ Ray Herman; Muhammad Izwan Ikhsan; Ku Mohd Amir Aizat Ku Yusof

doi:10.47405/mjssh.v8i10.2572

Hershan @ Ray Herman Department of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sabah Branch, 88997, Kota Kinabalu Campus, Sabah, Malaysia.
Muhammad Izwan Ikhsan Department of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sabah Branch, 88997, Kota Kinabalu Campus, Sabah, Malaysia.
Ku Mohd Amir Aizat Ku Yusof Department of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sabah Branch, 88997, Kota Kinabalu Campus, Sabah, Malaysia.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47405/mjssh.v8i10.2572

Keywords: Party hopping, Freedom of association, Party defection, Party loyalty, Democracy

Abstract

This article delves into the intricate dynamics of party loyalty and its implications for political stability in Malaysia, with a specific focus on party hopping. This study applies a doctrinal approach by examining statutory provisions, courts’ judgments and secondary sources. Through a detailed analysis of two landmark cases – Nordin Salleh and Khaliq Mehtab – this study uncovers the underlying challenges within Malaysia's political landscape. The analysis illuminates the judicial position in Nordin Salleh and the departure in Khaliq Mehtab’s cases; to which contrasting judicial positions were taken by the then Supreme Court in the former and the Federal Court in the latter. In light of these findings, the study underscores the critical need for robust and adaptable political institutions capable of withstanding such disruptions, thereby fostering a stable and resilient democracy. Furthermore, this study draws attention to the 2022 constitutional amendment addressing party hopping, acknowledging it as a positive step towards enhancing stability. However, it also highlights the existing gaps in the reforms, particularly in light of the pending application in court. In conclusion, this study posits that the constitutional amendment represents a commendable effort to advance political stability, but its efficacy remains to be seen.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abdul Ghafor, N. (2001). Pilihan Raya 1999: Satu analisis prestasi UMNO [Election 1999: An analysis of UMNO’s performance]. Masters thesis, Universiti Malaya.

Afif Bin Bahardin v Dewan Undangan Negeri Pulau Pinang & Anor [2023] MLJU 439

Anjumin, E. (2023, June 1). ''Sabah anti-party hopping laws should also apply to nominated assemblymen”. New Straits Times. Retrieved from https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2023/06/915529/sabah-anti-party-hopping-laws-should-also-apply-nominated-assemblymen

Carnell, F.G. (1955). The Malayan Elections. Pacific Affairs, 28(4), 315-330.

Chin, J. (1994). The Sabah State Election of 1994: End of Kadazan Unity. Asian Survey, 34(10), 904-915.

Dato' Seri Ir Hj Mohammad Nizar bin Jamaluddin v Dato' Seri Dr Zambry bin Abdul Kadir (Attorney General, intervener), [2010] 2 MLJ 285

Dewan Undangan Negeri Kelantan & Anor. v Nordin Salleh & Anor. [1992] 1 MLJ 697

Ee, K.C. & Yow, J. (2022, October 31). Anti party hopping laws introduced in Federal Constitution of Malaysia. Retrieved from https://www.rahmatlim.com/publication/articles/22605/anti-party-hopping-laws-introduced-in-federal-constitution-of-malaysia

Khairulrijal, R. (2023, April 28). Bersatu files judicial review to vacate four parliamentary seats in Sabah. New Straits Times. Retrieved from https://www.nst.com.my/news/crime-courts/2023/04/903751/bersatu-files-judicial-review-vacate-four-parliamentary-seats-sabah

Khaliq Mehtab bin Mohd Ishaq & Anor v Dewan Undangan Negeri Pulau Pinang & Anor [2023] MLJU 736

Khaliq Mehtab Mohd Ishaq & Anor v Dewan Undangan Negeri Pulau Pinang & Anor [2023] 9 MLJ 259

Kok, C.K. & Tan, W.L. (2022 August 1). Malaysia’s Anti-Party Hopping Law : A Compromised Law? Lexology. Retrieved from https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=bdb42f41-979c-498a-a67e-32bb7ad2e3b0

Lee, C. (2019). Economic Voting and the End of Dominant Party Rule in Malaysia. Economics Working Paper. ISEAS Yusof Ishak Institute. Retrieved from https://www.iseas.edu.sg/images/pdf/ISEASEWP2019-1Lee.pdf

Lynn, K.C.Y. (2023, January 9). Opening of the Legal Year Speech 2023: Speech by President of the Malaysian Bar [2023] 1 MLJ xviii

Majid, A., Karim, R., Thanasegaran, H. & Lee, M.Y. (2022). The Federal Court Overrules the Decision on the Party-Hopping case Dewan Undangan Negeri Kelantan & Anor v Nordin Salleh & Anor [1992] 1 MLJ 697 [2022] 4 MLJ li

Moten, A.R. (2023). Research Note: The 15th General Elections in Malaysia. ISEAS - Yusof Ishak Institute, 45(1), 111-127.

Nadzri, M.M.N. (2019). The 14th General Election, the Fall of Barisan Nasional, and Political Development in Malaysia, 1957 - 2018. Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 37(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/186810341803700307

Ng, S.F. (2022 October 19). Malaysia’s Anti-hopping Law: Some Loopholes to Mull Over. Fulcrum: Analysis on Southeast Asia. retrieved from https://fulcrum.sg/malaysias-anti-hopping-law-some-loopholes-to-mull-over/

Pattaro, E. (2005). A treatise of legal philosophy and general jurisprudence. New York: Springer.

Pillay, C. (1974). The 1974 General Elections in Malaysia, Singapore: ISEAS Publishing https://doi.org/10.1355/9789814380072

Pumuye, G.M. (2021). Discussion Paper No. 2021/4: Restricting Party Hopping in Papua New Guinea’s Parliament. Department of Pacific Affairs, Australian National University.

Reference Re Public Service Employee Relations Act (Alberta) [1987] 1 S.C.R. 313

Rudner, M. (1970). The Malaysian General Election of 1969: A Political Analysis. Modern Asian Studies, 4(1), 1-21. doi:10.1017/S0026749X00010957

Saidin, M.I.S. (2023). Malaysia’s crisis of political legitimacy: Understanding the 2020 power transition and ‘Sheraton Move’ polemics through the ‘eyes’ of Malaysian political science graduates. Cogent Social Sciences, 9(1), 2222572.

Sodial, K. (2022). Anti-Defection Law and Its Loopholes. Indian Journal of Law and Legal Research, 4, 1-7.

Sun, C.K. (2022). The Fall of the Pakatan Harapan (PH): Contesting Nationalism in Malaysia. Honours thesis, Western Michigan University.

Thomas, T. (2016). Abuse of Power. Selected Works on the Law and Constitution [Review of Abuse of Power: Selected Works on the Law and Constitution]. Strategic Information and Research Development Centre.

Vasil, R. K. (1965). The 1964 General Elections in Malaya. International Studies, 7(1), 20–65. doi:10.1177/002088176500700102

Weiss, M. L. (2013), Coalitions and Competition in Malaysia – Incremental Transformation of a Strong-party System. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 32(2), 19–37.

Wong, C.H. & Wo, C.X. (2022). Advancing Democratic Representation, Stability and Accountability: Regulating Change of Party Affiliation in Malaysia. Selangor: Jeffrey Sachs Center on Sustainable Development.

Yusoff, M. A. (2001). Sabah Politics Under Pairin. Malaysian Journal of Science, 6, 29–48.

Zulkifli bin Ibrahim v Dewan Undangan Negeri Pulau Pinang & Anor [2023] MLJU 440